Question: when is the eid? majority says its today on the 20th september 2009. please if posible rply now cause i need to know it tody itself. thank you
Answer: Pehli ka chand 5 tareeqo say sabit hota hay: 1)Insaan Chand khud daikhay. 2)Aisay khuch loog kahain jin k kehnay say yaqeen(100%) haasil hojaay. 3)2 aadil merd kahain k hum nay khud daikha hay. 4)Pichlay mahinay k 30 din guzar jain. 5)Mujtahid hokum day k aaj chand ki pehli hogae hay.(ref:Ayat ullah Khumeni,Tauzee hul masail, maslah#1727) .
Question: I came from Saudi Arabia and now in Pakistan for Eid you know in Saudi ramzan started one day before so I will follow the Eid with Pakistan or Saudi arabia
Answer: You must follow your current zone now for moon. (Ref:Ayat Ullah Seestani(d.b), Tauzee hul masael,Edition# 35,Mafhoom e Maslah #). Update on dated 17-07-2015. (Khuda aap ko Uloom e Aal e Muhammad(s.a.w.w) sekhne ka ajar ata farmaey).
Question: Kaya chand nikal ne ki khaber mard ke mo se sonne caheye keya haddess me likha ha
Answer: “Shoib bin yaqoob hazrat imam jaffer sadiq a.s se or wo apne walid e maajid se riwayat kerte hain k hazrat ameer a.s fermate hain k talaq or chand k maamlay main sirif 2(adil) merdo ki gawahi ko nafiz samajhta hoon”, “Hammaad bin usman hazrat imam jaffer sadiq a.s se riwayat kerte hain fermaya: Hazrat ameer a.s ne fermaya hay k chand k baaray main aurtoo ki shahadat jaiz(naafiz) nahi hay or sirif 2 aadil merdo ki shahadat jaiz (naafiz) hay”. (Ref: Wasaelush shia jild #7, kitabus saum, Ahkaam e maah e ramazan k abwaab ka baab #11). Update on dated 31-03-17. (Khuda aap ko Uloom e Aal e Muhammad(s.a.w.w) sekhne ka ajar ata farmaey).
Question: assalam o alaikum pakistan mein agr kisi bhi elaqe mein chand nazar aa jaye to kya doosre elaqon wale bhi use apna chand krar de skte hain?? for example: agr karachi me chand nazar aa jaye aur pindi-islamabad me na aye to islamabad walo k lye kya hukam hai
Answer:
Question: Assalamo alaikum janab ham yaham dubai me rahte hai yahan har sal tamazan aur eid ke chand me kashmakash rahti hai kyoki sare marja e taqlid ki janib se tarikh aage rahti hai aur ayatullah ali sistani sahab ki taraf se 1din piche rahti hai yani kisi ki eid hoti hai kisi ka roza hota hai kya sab ka roza aur sabki eid ek sath nahi ho sakti meharbani karke is masle ka hal jald se jald bata de shukriya
Answer:
Question: I am studying and living in China for the last two years. China is a non-Muslim country. Few Muslims in my city, particularly, follow Saudi Arabia during the Holy month of Ramzan, starting and ending according to Saudi Arabia calender. If we see on the world map, and according to my understanding, China must follow Pakistan, instead of Saudi Arabia, because China is 5 hours ahead than Saudi Arabia in time as well. Therefore, how is it possible that moon can be visible in China before Pakistan. I am not expert to do some mathematical calculations to give correct approximation according to change in geography. Therefore, I want to follow Pakistan in terms of Ramzan Fasting Calender rather than to follow the Chinese schedule which is basically following Saudi Arabia. Although, most of the Muslims in my city, particularly Pakistanis, follow Saudi Arabia. Please tell me either can I follow Pakistan rather than Saudi Arabia or not? Because Pakistani Ramzan Calender is appealing me much more than Saudi Arabian's because of geographical location of Pakistan and China. In addition, my living city Hanzhou is in East China. Much far away from Saudi Arabia and even from Pakistan's border as well. Moreover, I have seen that Chinese Muslims offered Eid ul Fitr Prayer on second of Shawal last year and there was no fasting on 1st of Ramzan, because they need to take permission from government for Eid Prayer at least one day before the event (as I heard about it). This is information of my living city in China. Hence, Pakistan's Ramzan Fasting schedule is much appealing me to follow rather than Saudi Arabian's while living in Hangzhou, China. But it is a critical issue as most Pakistani's living here are following Saudi Arabia, even such contradictions are also present in Pakistan Therefore I am consulting a scholar to advice me in this matter. Looking for a prompt reply please, as the month of Ramzan is very close to start.
Answer: